Log In or Create Account
Back to Blog
PERSONAL

7

2,930
Exposure!
5 years ago - Edited 5 years ago2,304 words
Memody: Sindrel Song is out now. The previous post is a quick announcement of that; this is a more in-depth ramble about my feelings related to it.

I'm not really feeling all that much at all. When I released on Kartridge months ago, there was a lot of anxious build-up, expecting much more of a response than it actually got. I still got some anxiety this morning, but since pressing the Release button, I've not been stressed about it at all really. Mostly I'm just tired. This whole thing's dragged on a while.

Maybe it'll pick up as America's evening comes, or over the weekend, or maybe it'll slowly gain traction over the coming months, but I doubt it. A couple of months ago, I wrote ∞ a post about a random indie game I saw announced on Reddit's r/gaming. ∞ I've not actually played the game, still, but I kept its store page open in a tab out of curiosity, to see whether the interest would grow over time or not. It didn't; the amount of reviews it has now is about the same as the amount it had on the day I found it. Release week is everything, probably.

Which is a shame, since I can't imagine I'll be doing anything to promote it. I'll be lucky if it manages to beat Kartridge in sales (it has 24 on there; wow, like 6 I think since release week!!!).

I have been getting a bunch of emails from people asking for free access keys though. Here's an example:

Hi, I'm [gamerdudeMcNumbers] and I own a Twitch channel dedicated to high-quality game streaming. I'm looking for new AAA or indie projects to play on my channel now and your game looks so good to me! Could you support me with steam press key of InsertGameNameHere? Also some copies for a promotion to my subs would be great too if possible.
Thanks!


Or they say they're 'curators' rather than Twitch streamers. I keep wanting to reply with something like:

Hello, I'm the developer of Memody: Sindrel Song, and I'm dedicated to creating high-quality indie games. I'm looking for players willing to pay money for my games so that the months spent developing them wasn't wasted. Could you support me with the not-at-all expensive payment to acquire the game? Also, buying several copies would benefit me even more.
Thanks!


But I can't imagine it'd go down well, so I'm just not replying at all.

Here's the end bit of another:

We are committed to recommending excellent games to everyone, and of course we will leave our most sincere feelings. If you believe in us, please send us 2 copies, we can upload my review of your game to our website,we will live up to your expectations. I am very grateful and i will promote it.Finally, I wish you a better sale of your game and your career will flourish.

Cheers!
Boy_Killer


Something about that suggests any kind of recommendation they might provide might not be all that appropriate for this game, though I can't quite put my finger on it, hmmmmm.

When I released on Kartridge, I got a few emails like this, and thought wow, opportunities! I should take these or I'll regret it! So I gave out a bunch of keys. Some weren't even claimed, and none of them resulted in anything that was of any benefit to me. I read into it a bit, and a lot of other indie developers had been similarly hopeful and trusting, only to see their freely-given gifts resold, unused, or maybe if they were lucky they got a couple of 200-view videos in which a couple of minutes of the game (without any mention of its title) appeared sandwiched between political rants or something.

It's awful, since it's not as if indie developers are raking in the cash (except in very rare cases). It's so predatory, and I wonder how these people justify it to themselves. Do they feel that they're so important they shouldn't have to pay?

Perhaps in theory these 'influencer' types could inspire sales, or at least that seems to be the widely-held idea, but I wonder how often this kind of exposure actually does benefit the developers. I read a post on r/gamedev where someone said that even if you strike it big and get one of the top youtubers/streamers playing your game, getting millions of views, maybe around 2000 of them - at best - would convert into actual sales. That's not a negligible amount, but I suspect that the amount of conversions from a much more obscure video maker would be. It just doesn't seem worth the stress and effort.

I can't imagine a stream in particular helping conversion. If people are watching the game in that format, they're probably not going to buy it because they've already seen it. It's like someone asking for a copy of a film to show to his friends, saying 'they might buy the (whatever they use instead of DVDs now) later!'

It's not a million miles away from designers ∞ commonly complaining about clients asking them to do free work because it'll give them 'exposure' ∞, as if that's worth the time it takes.



So what, then? Do I turn down all these wonderful offers and get no 'exposure' at all? It feels like if someone really cares about helping out the developer and believes their own videos will do well, they'd just pay for the thing. $10 is nothing. If you need the game for free, why? Are you not expecting to gain anything from what you make? I keep wanting to ask them that too (but don't).

But how else are games even promoted? I've been thinking for the past few days that maybe I could at least post on r/gamedev or something, where a lot of people in a similar position congregate, but it seems they're all trying to promote their own games rather than looking at anyone else's, and there are actually rules in place to prevent sharing your own games for this reason. So that's not really an option. I've no idea where else I could even talk about it. How do people even find obscure indie games?

I mean, anxiety definitely gets in the way, but mostly it's just not knowing where to promote.

Though I also feel very conflicted about Sindrel Song as a project. I like what I did with it, and I consider the creation process and the end result valuable. But it's fairly obvious that it's not widely appealing, that it's frustrating or weird or just not the kind of fun most people would enjoy. So I don't want to inflict that on others, especially if it'd lead to painful criticism. I don't really want to expose it too clearly to the daggers of the masses.



The 'story' - though I don't really think of it as a story as such - of MSS was largely inspired by my experiences with Avoidant Personality Disorder. That's also what gets in the way of promoting it, and makes me not want to 'inflict it on others', out of fear of criticism.

Last night, I looked at the subreddit for this disorder, ∞ r/AvPD ∞, after avoiding it for weeks after someone suggested it to me. It's disappointingly small, at least compared to the huge communities, though I suppose it's not smaller than Fig Hunter was, back when I felt that was a thriving community. Interesting, that; mice are tiny to elephants, but gargantuan compared to most creatures on the planet.

I mention this because the posts on there definitely resonate with me. We all do seem to have essentially the same thing. If you've read my blog for a while and wondered what exactly this AvPD thing is, what it's like to live with it, or it's seemed baffling or alien to you, I'd recommend having a look at that, even just spending a few seconds skimming through the titles of the top few best posts this past month, or all time. There are a lot of parallels between what people say there and what I've said here.

Differences too, though. Many of them have jobs and families, which I've never managed to acquire. But many also talk about having done nothing with their lives, so what I've managed to make might seem either impressive or irritating to them, even if I also feel I've done nothing - or am doing nothing - with mine. A recurring theme is being scared to speak honestly about their feelings or experiences, to share, which is something I do too much. Their filters and shells are too thick, mine are paper thin, if even there at all. Both lead to issues in different ways. They don't let anyone close, and feel alone. I get too close and drive people away, and feel alone.

I was surprised by the number of people in their mid-30's or older, who see the world and their place in it much the same way I see mine. Being wrong, different, not meant for this world; suicide's the inevitable outcome, it's just a matter of when, not if. Five more years? Ten? The simple pleasures of others are inaccessible; everyone just knows how to be human in a way they - we - seemingly don't. They mentioned trying again and again to overcome their problems, only to find themselves back where they started every time, and now they're just too tired. I've been there. I am there now.

Maybe you're thinking reading things like this is bad for me because it'd just encourage hopeless thinking. O woe is me! What's the point of it all! But reading it all inspired a kind of determination. I don't want to still be like this several years from now, still held back by the same problems. I don't want to resign myself to a life of stacking shelves or living on benefits because I let the years pass me by, hiding away, possessed by these damn demons. I feel I need to read things like that more often so then I'm inspired to try to do something about it!

After reading something about neglecting social connections, I messaged a couple of people I suppose are friends, but who I haven't spoken to in a while. A little thing, but something. Neither have replied yet; maybe I waited too long and the bridges rotted away. This is a recurring theme people talk about in that community, too; delaying for so long that you miss your opportunity, things fade from neglect.

I wanted to message a couple of other people too, but I can't imagine they'd want to hear from me. Part of the condition is assuming that about everyone, that nobody could possibly have a positive impression so it's best to isolate to avoid inflicting myself upon them, but sometimes that probably is the actual truth of the matter. They don't want me to talk to them. They want me gone.

I've been thinking about that more than Sindrel Song... I suppose it's a distraction from the anxiety, if nothing else?



I veered away from the original point there, but I suppose now that Sindrel Song is 'done', in a sense, I've been thinking a lot about where to go next. I feel like I'm developing a clearer plan for how I want next year to go. I've already touched on it in recent posts, but I'm going to do that again because it helps to clarify some things to myself.

I'm currently playing through MARDEK, and I'll definitely release that early next year. Now doesn't seem wise with Christmas upcoming, especially since it takes weeks for Steam to approve anything. Maybe February's better than January, if people would be busy with their Christmas gifts? How well that goes would give me an idea of how viable this path is.

I've got old games like Clarence's Big Chance ready to upload on this site, but I'm wondering when the best time is to do that. I can't imagine they'd earn any money anyway, but I might as well upload them anyway in the hope someone might spare a few dollars. (I wonder if I'd get more literally begging on the streets for a day...)

I definitely need to talk (or - ugh - *network*) with people more, but I think I'll start doing that when people come to me about MARDEK. I'll try to gather up at least a little bit of interest that would help to run a successful Kickstarter campaign for a MARDEK remake.

This month and next, I should look into making a demo/early version of that remake, to go with the Kickstarter. Or at least I can write story plans, etc; that takes a while.

I'll also look into seeing a therapist, again, despite the lack of use they've been in the past. Rather than working through general CBT or whatever, I'll present them specific problems: "I need to research this thing but I'm putting it off, so sit there as I do it in front of you so then I stop putting it off!" Insane, but it might have practical benefits. What I feel I need most is exposure therapy, but it's very difficult to do that alone. Just having someone present to immediately report to makes it infinitely easier, for me at least.

If things still haven't picked up this time next year, well... I'll just try to focus on this for now.

7 COMMENTS

Astreon152~5Y
Wow, you already found your new year's resolutions :)

Seriously, it's already been said, but it seems like ever since your surgery and Memody, you've changed as if...you leveled up from your 20ish self ? Or maybe evolved, like some pokemon ?

Still have issues, but are handling them much better, and you're way more positive than before, even if you try to make it sound like resignation rather than hope :)

I wish you the best for 2020, may you be able to carry out what you're aiming for, both in mind and games !

4
purplerabbits148~5Y
I have seen so many people trying to exchange free promotion for free stuff. However, those people have such a small following that it's pretty obvious that they only want free stuff. I'm guessing the idea of free promotion comes from people seeing big people like the Pewdiepie's, Jacksepticeye's, and Markiplier's, mention that a company sent them free stuff. But those influencers also said that they bought an extra copy/item because they really believe and enjoy the game/product. And also, there are laws where you have to clearly disclose whether you are sponsored by a product or not.

And with a free promotion the developer has more to lose, especially when it comes to the type of people who go around asking for stuff in exchange of free promotion.

I get what you mean about not wanting to "inflict" yourself on others. It's the "fun" thing about being an introvert :') (or a depressed one at least). If you spend too much time with people, then your social meter explodes, but then if you withdraw from people for too long then your social meter implodes.

I'm glad that you have a plan on how to approach the anxiety and avoidant personality disorder. :D

2
MontyCallay101~5Y
Don't worry about Sindrel Song! Now it's in the past, and even if you maybe should have done more to promote it, I think you're better off focusing on the present now. The key may be to develop some sort of concrete promotion strategy beforehand that you can stick to.
I'm glad to be one of those people who have bought the game on Steam! I've not reviewed it yet, but probably will over the coming days.
Yeah, I think you're right to be sceptical of those people asking for free keys. You're not really in the spotlight anyway, so what you do get is probably just people writing a template with [InsertGameNameHere] to get keys to resell etc. There's actually online shops out there that make quite a lot of money selling Steam keys for lower prices than the actual ones on Steam, and they make their money through schemes like that and so on… it gets quite shady. It may be a matter of having to divide the wheat from the chaff (having a look at their websites, streams etc.) should you eventually go on to seriously promote one of your games. As for how those people justify it to themselves, I have no idea – I suppose it's a living, somehow?

On the other hand, I think you shouldn't disregard the idea of "influencer types" promoting sales – If influencers aren't worth it, are journalists worth it? Is marketing at all worth it? I think the point in this case is that exposure over time and through different channels may yield valuable results in the end. I think it's actually more or less standard practice for developers to send out some free steam keys to influencers and journalists whom they consider to be significant in order to receive some sort of favourable coverage. Honestly, that's the sort of thing that you should research for yourself, and the way to research that might be to communicate directly with other people in the industry, difficult though that may seem. You could probably learn a lot more that way than just by pure guesswork or random Google searches. Ultimately, I suppose it's a matter of building up your *network* as you said, annoying though that may be at times… but it's a tough industry you're trying to make a living in in the first place!

I think that Sindrel Song as a project is, as you put it some time earlier, idiosyncratic, but not necessarily off-putting in the "oh, what a disgusting weirdo is this guy" sort of way – you'd certainly not be *inflicting* anything on anybody else if you gave them some interesting or challenging perspectives. Some artists pride themselves on provoking or challenging people with their art in novel ways, and though I don't see Sindrel Song as doing that, it's clear you had a vision and that you stuck to it! And that's an intriguing thing regardless, especially with your own story.

I looked at the subreddit you linked, and I have mixed feelings, as you predicted – it's the sort of thing that *to me* seems to be the opposite of constructive, self-improving thinking, to just dwell in darkness like that – it was actually a bit uncomfortable to read those posts on there, since they reached some of my own anxieties as well. But, of course, everybody needs a place to vent, etc. etc., so I can hardly fault those folks for doing that. It just seems so bleak, so wrong to me, to give into defeatism like that. But if you can take that as a source of determination for your own aspirations, go ahead! Honestly, I think what you said about needing exposure therapy may very well be true. It's so easy to consider yourself a lost cause when you're holed up away from other people in your room, since you lack the perspective that interaction with the world can offer – so I think it's a good idea to seek companionship with other people wherever you can, if the opportunity presents itself. Even if you are rejected every once in a while, I've found that the act of being rejected is less significant than all the worrying and anxiety done about it – and there's nothing to be lost taking a chance!

I've read a lot of your "New Year's aspirations" posts throughout the years, and I have to say that you're coming the closest I've ever seen to really setting up concrete strategies to achieve your goals – before, I had a feeling it was more of a "I'd like to have X at the end of the year" type of thing – so the direction you're on right now is great! I think seeing a therapist in particular, at least, can't hurt – at the very least it's another source of exposure to the world that you might find useful.

If you do concretely work on those issues, I have no doubt that things will pick up for you! With your abilities and your self-reflectiveness, honestly, if you can't make things work, who can?
2
Dingding32167~5Y
I looked through some of the thread and this one stood out to me:
[LINK]

Not sure if that's a personal thing for me to always focus on improvement, either self or otherwise, but it's good to see someone else voicing their mixed opinions on the thread and determination to change, and especially that one particular comment from Zanderleigh about therapy and rethinking the condition. I have no personal experience with this, but I can definitely empathise with how desperate and desolate varying degrees of social isolation can be. And I can definitely relate to "accidentally" reacting to what could just be an overreaction to perceived rejection, but might not actually be. In a good state of mind, I'd brush it off and give them the benefit of the doubt, knowing that if I make more of an effort or at least stay neutral things are more likely to be better and might progress, but it's much easier said than done. Honestly, most people simply don't care or don't mind, as long as they're not giving up much--time, attention or otherwise. I think the key really is just to find what you want to talk about, and other people who want to talk about that, which at least is a start. Work of whatever sort does seem to help as well, just from the constant *exposure*, as you mentioned, and I've always liked sticking to professional relationships or ones you simply have to spend time with others in to get to know people, rather than make the leap of faith to "go out for a casual chat or coffee" or anything of that sort.

I think people generally do appreciate the sentiment behind you reaching out in some way, especially if they themselves are busy; though generally it's awkward if you're wanting to get something out of it, even in terms of social interaction. I guess people don't like being used, innocuous as it might be. It's probably worth messaging those other people you thought about messaging, since you even thought about doing so and actually wanted to! I've just stopped trying to read too much into responses or lack thereof, people are just *always busy* or meant to reply and then forget. I used to judge people or be disappointed at their *lack of self-discipline* but I've realised how life can complicate things.

I'm glad you've got your next steps sorted out! I'll hopefully have time to download and play MSS over Christmas. You're completely justified in not giving away free codes, especially for such an in-depth experience that can't really be condensed into a "quick gameplay demo video" for mindless mass-consumption like they seem to be offering.

Edit: another thought— volunteering is a really good way to get that casual exposure while actually doing something (which gives you an excuse and makes you feel better as well, since you're doing something for others and you can see the direct results quite easily), which I highly recommend! I know there's no "money" in it but for social isolation and feeling better I think it's immensely valuable. There are lots of different types even if you're not a social person— I do conservation work outdoors which doesn't take much talking but gives me a chance to meet others as well and talk if we want to. It also self-selects a certain type of person who's less likely to be hedonistic or hands-off/ unwilling to put in effort, which I appreciate. Meeting more mature people (mentally) certainly helps, especially older people who usually have different perspectives on life and are less sensitize to social pressure. Hope that helps in some way, at least as a thought experiment!
1
bluefunday6~5Y
I see that you released the soundtrack on steam with Sindrel Song. Would you release it on other platforms? (I am asking because I bought it on Kartridge.... -_-;)
0
Tobias 1115~5Y
It's not likely worth the effort, unfortunately. It takes ages to get things set up correctly, and I imagine you'd be the only person to buy it on there. It's possible to get just the soundtrack alone on Steam, I think?
0
bluefunday6~5Y
Nope... It is a dlc sadly.... Need base game. If you do release your soundtrack on spotify or some independent platform, please let me know. I will gladly purchase it.
1
Log in to comment!